I just got back from a long workout at the Gym. I have been far too lax with my workout schedule this summer, and I am pretty sure I know why. I had back surgery in 2000, which has made it virtually impossible for me to do any of the physical activities that I love: Running, Running, and Running. In fact, running was the single-most therapeutic thing I did for myself every day for years. When I was in graduate school and first discovered that I suffered from depression, it was running that always pulled me out.
One summer I had foolishly agreed to give "psychoanalysis" a try, which meant I had to go to therapy three times a week. A lot of grad students were reading Lacan and Freud, and I got swept up with this rather linguistic approach to my depression. I thought if I sat on the couch, talked about my life, my fears, my dreams and my reaction to literature (?) I would be able to untangle whatever was pinning me down and feel better. Instead, I found the whole process to be demoralizing. I would drive 2 hours (roundtrip) for my appointments, and then I would basically have extremely theoretical conversations about identity or melancholia. Every once in awhile the analyst would try the whole transference process, which would kind of creep me out (there are no feelings in philosophy!) and I finally had to quit.
Luckily, I was about to head up to Vermont to study French that summer, so I had a natural break from him. While in Middlebury, I would take runs in the countryside, the cross-country course and the woods twice a day (between my two morning classes and then before dinner). Within two weeks, I was pulling myself out of the tunnel. I looked forward to every day, rather than find excuses to stay huddled under the covers.
By the end of the summer, I was fully alive (except my feet were pretty mashed up from long runs). I wrote a letter to my analyst: "I have decided to discontinue analysis because I discovered that running was the best antidote to my misery . . . ". My analyst tried to get me to come back to our sessions, probably because he was in training and needed the patients, but I refused. I started entering races, joined the New York Road Runners club and found any stretch of forest I could to run in.
All that stopped when my back fell apart during my second year of teaching. I tried to start running again after my surgery, but 8 mos. later I was losing feeling in my left leg again. So, now all that I can do is ride the stationary bike. It is so boring, totally uninspiring, although it keeps me in shape.
A colleague of mine was working out near me today. She is probably 10 years older than me and in the best shape of anyone that I know. She was doing a long run and I caught myself staring at her in total envy. Not only did she look like she was in that endorphin zone that is heaven to me, but she is in fantastic shape. She looks strong, capable, determined, and she glows.
Just as I was getting off my lame ole bike, one of the gym employees walked up to her and said: "Wow you are really working out hard these days. Are you trying to get in shape for a wedding or something?" I felt my face get flush with anger. Here was this godlike woman, doing what I wish I could do, and possessing all of the strength and centeredness from it that I wish I had, and butthead had to demean it.
I know, I know, you think I am overreacting. Perhaps I am. But, I thought more about my reaction before I wrote this down. What I really hated about that comment was how little insight this guy had into the immeasurable healing power of physical sport. Running, in particular, is like a spiritual activity to me, especially if you go out into the woods and do it (the gym really is a lame place to do it . . .). Feeling yourself to be that strong and powerful is also one of the best antidepressants. But, he turned it into a vanity thing. Worse, he turned it into a temporary vanity thing for a wedding--like she was doing this for someone else, so that someone else would find her a glowing bride.
You know what, maybe she is for all I know. Maybe she does run and push herself to those extremes so that she looks as gorgeous as she does for the male gaze. But, I sort of hope that isn't the only reason.
"Running, in particular, is like a spiritual activity to me, especially if you go out into the woods and do it (the gym really is a lame place to do it . . .). Feeling yourself to be that strong and powerful is also one of the best antidepressants."
ReplyDeleteOn a curious side observation, I find the combination of these statements rather interesting. Running is in no way shape or form a spiritual activity to me. In fact, I feel downright combative when I workout. I really didn't even enjoy running all that much until I began running races (inspired by John L. Parker Jr.'s excellent book Once a Runner) that I developed any passion for it. I never get the "runners high" (at least as it is described, or a feeling comprable to the feeling I get while backpacking) so oft described, and my running experience seems to be, on an emotional level, quite different than yours.
Yet, I completly agree with the second statement I quoted from your entry. I get the same sensation of strength and power from running. What this has really gotten me thinking about is the difference in interpretation of what is in all likelihood, the same biological process. With my astoundingly small knowledge of biochemistry, I'm thinking there is some sort of release of endorphins that trigger the euphoric sensations. If the author, or soul searcher wants to correct me, please do.
So, while the root process, and biological causes are presumably similar, the way we mentally frame it is completly different. What you perceive as the enjoyable aspect of the activity is, in many ways, completly different than my own perceptions. Clearly I'm just sort of making stuff up, but seems like an interesting line all the same.
Jeff--
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, we would probably have to clarify what we mean by "spriritual" . . . For me, I think of spiritual as connected to spirited (combative).
But, beyond that, I think another interesting thing to pursue in our differing interpretations of the biochemical experience is how our self-understanding as gendered affects the interpretation. What do you think?
Where is soul searcher???
Ah, I think the way I interpreted spiritual is quite different from your intended meaning.
ReplyDeleteI certainly think the gender angle is an interesting way to approach the problem. Personally, I was approaching it from a more individualistic angle, but I could imagine approaching it from a gender-related angle does give you a foot up since it allows for the application of a single gender role to the question, rather than the varying qualities of an individual.
Wow...wish I had some of these sensations when running. To me it's always been the closest thing to pure torture...haha. I've always seen running as only a means to an end, i.e. getting in shape for football, wrestling. I don't really recall a "combative" feeling from running and definitely never a "high." If it is essentially the same biochem process going on, as I would imagine it is, then I've come to frame it completely differently than either of you.
ReplyDeleteTom--
ReplyDeleteYou crack me up. Somehow I thought you might respond to my blog entry this way! LOL!
I am surprised, however, that both you and Jeff don't get the runner's high. It is so fantastic. But, I always needed just the right conditions: cool weather, running path through the woods, etc.
:)